How we rate prop firms
Every listed firm gets a score from 0 to 10. It is calculated, not voted: seven parts with fixed weights, filled with data from the firm's own pages. The same formula applies to every firm, whether it pays for a listing or not.
The seven parts and their weights
| Part | Weight | What goes in |
|---|---|---|
| Cost | 20% | Fee for the reference account (100K forex/CFD, 50K futures), ranked against firms of the same market type. |
| Trading rules | 20% | Size and type of the max loss, daily loss limit, minimum days, time limit and consistency rule. |
| Payouts | 20% | Profit split, time to the first payout and payout frequency. |
| Reputation | 15% | Trustpilot rating weighted by number of reviews, plus years in business. |
| Trading freedom | 10% | News trading, holding over the weekend, EAs/bots and copy trading. |
| Platforms & markets | 10% | Number of supported platforms and tradable markets. |
| Transparency | 5% | How many key facts the firm publishes clearly enough for us to verify. |
The overall score is the weighted sum of the seven part scores, rounded to one decimal. Firms that are closed or paused are not scored.
The reference account
To compare like with like we pick one account per firm: the size closest to $100,000 for forex and CFD firms and closest to $50,000 for futures firms. If a firm sells several programs at that size, we take the cheapest one. Prices are list prices without discounts.
How each part is calculated
Cost (20%)
We convert the reference price to US dollars and scale it to the reference size. Monthly futures subscriptions count as 1.5 months, because most traders need more than one month to pass. One-time activation fees are added. Firms are then ranked against firms of the same market type: the cheapest gets 10, the most expensive gets 2, everyone else in between by rank.
Trading rules (20%)
Starts at 5 and moves with the rules of the reference program:
- Max loss of 10% or more: +2; 8% to 10%: +1; 6% to 8%: +0.3; 4% to 6%: -0.3; below 4%: -1.
- Drawdown type: static +1.5, end-of-day trailing +0.3, trailing -0.7, intraday trailing -1.2.
- No daily loss limit: +1. Daily loss of 5% or more: +0.3. Below 3%: -0.5.
- No minimum trading days: +0.6. Five days or more: -0.5.
- No time limit: +0.5. A time limit: -1.
- A consistency rule: -0.5.
Payouts (20%)
Base value from the profit split: 100% gives 9.5, 90% gives 8.5, 80% gives 7, 70% gives 5.5, lower gives 4. Then: first payout within 7 days +1, within 14 days +0.4, after more than 21 days -1. A split that can rise later +0.3. Weekly or on-demand payouts +0.4.
Reputation (15%)
From the Trustpilot rating and the number of reviews: (rating minus 3) times 3.2, plus up to 3 points for review volume on a logarithmic scale. Years in business add up to 1 point. A firm that is closed or paused loses 4 points. Without a Trustpilot profile the part starts at 4.
Trading freedom (10%)
News trading, weekend holding, EAs and copy trading: 2.5 points each if allowed, 1.3 if allowed with restrictions, 0 if banned, 1 if the firm does not say.
Platforms and markets (10%)
1.5 points per supported platform (up to 6) and 0.8 points per tradable market (up to 4).
Transparency (5%)
Starts at 10. Every key fact we cannot verify from the firm's own pages costs 0.8 points. A completed second check adds 0.5.
Where the data comes from
- The firm's own website, help center and terms. Every figure on a profile links to the page it came from, with the date we read it.
- Trustpilot for the public rating and review count, with the check date.
- A second check: before a profile goes live, a second person checks price, drawdown, daily loss, split, first payout, platforms and US eligibility against the sources again.
If a figure cannot be verified, we show "n/a" and list it under "Not verified" on the profile. We do not guess.
What payment can and cannot buy
Firms pay to be listed and can buy labeled ad space (see how we make money). Payment does not enter the formula. A paying firm with weak rules scores low, and a firm that stops paying keeps the score its data earns until it is removed.
Updates and corrections
Profiles are re-checked regularly and whenever a firm announces a rule change. Firms and traders can send corrections with a source link through our contact page. When a change affects the score, the new score applies from the date of the change.